DISCUSSION Labour’s Employee Ownership Plan: not so inclusive after all

by Mark Goyder _______24th September 2018
Share

Two weeks ago I praised John McDonnell for plans to spread share ownership. Now more details have emerged and I’ve changed my mind.

When I was with Labour Business speaking at their conference fringe 2 years ago I recommended a requirement for LARGE LISTED companies to set aside a percentage of their PROFITS into an employee shareholding trust which would act in the long-term interests of employees. This would align workers and shareholders interests with the long-term performance of the company and steadily build a long-term employee stake as has been done by Handelsbanken.

McDonnell has now proposed that ALL companies with more than 250 staff must set aside 1% of EQUITY every year to an ‘Inclusive Ownership Fund’ (IOF).

Some questions for Labour:

• Why is the threshold set as numbers of staff not turnover?
• How can you apply this irrespective of profitability or loss making?
• Have you calculated the implications for ordinary people’s retirement income?
• Why not focus on listed companies at least initially and leave well-run private businesses to make their own decisions?
• Why a share of equity and not a share of profits? (The first is expropriation; the second would be sharing success.)
• And what safeguards are there to ensure that the governance of the IOF would be focused on the long-term benefit of the employee shareholders and not on extraction of short-term rent? (If you are going to promote employee shareholders you should at least ensure they are long-termist ones.)

I want to be open-minded but need to be persuaded that McDonnell and Labour have a stewardship rather than extractive view of the role of shareholders. So far, it sounds as they are more interested in dispossessing shareholders than creating a climate of shared wealth creation. If so using the word ‘Inclusive’ is an abuse of the spirit of Tomorrow’s Company which introduced the word into the debate about business 24 years ago.

To improve public procurement – use the Trust Test

Public procurement is too often solely made on price, and not enough on true value and to account for areas...

Serving All? How can employers support financial inclusion?

In January 2020, Tomorrow's Company co-hosted a major Financial Inclusion Summit, to launch our report into the role of employers...

Five ways businesses can think differently about mental health

Mental health in the workplace has gone from a fringe idea to being mainstream and top of the agenda in…

How can we #BalanceforBetter? By celebrating being good enough

Too often gender balance only celebrates women who have broken the glass ceiling. We need to do better for everyone...

Our favourite stories this week January 1-6 2019

Dear Readers, Here are a few articles published in the last few days that address issues – such as mental…

Featured Voice: Helen Buhaenko

We need a social contract that is fair, so that everyone has the chance to progress.

csuite podcast #76 – How connected brands drive growth

Joining Russell Goldsmith at the London offices of GSK to discuss this issue, were Kerry O'Callaghan, VP for Global Brand...

csuite podcast #75 – Social Mobility Live, 2018

Tomorrow’s Company is proud to announce a partnership with the c suite podcast, a monthly show covering topics such as Marketing…